Petzl Tactikka

Rating: 4.5 / 5

Pros:
Comfortable and light, long runtime, common AAA batteries, perfect general work/path lighting output

Cons:
Red filter is ineffective, producing a bright orange light with lots of white bleed; only one output level

The Bottom Line:
This is a great headlight, however for only $5 more the Tactikka Plus has an extra LED, strobe setting and 3 output levels.

It took forever to get this in from Botach (seriously, don’t order ANYTHING but closeout items from them if you need it this year), but they had the best price by a good 20% and were the only place I could find that carries the camo version (the other one is black with big ugly white logos): Petzl Tactikka @ Botach.

The light itself has been upgraded from the unit pictured on the site, and has the Tactikka Plus style ratchet adjustment for tilting the light to the preferred angle. Granted we didn’t come anywhere close to using them for the advertised 110-hour runtime, but they did not fade at all on a 5 hour night hike (actually, the return leg of a 10 hour hike). They are light enough to be comfortable despite running on 3 AAAs, and are adjustable from helmet-size all the way down to thigh size.

Their built-in red filter is kind of a joke, ending up with a bright orange and a lot of white bleed out the sides. It is handy for working on something up close I suppose, though the white light is not terribly overpowering. While I still grab for my Surefire to investigate sounds or search along the side of the trail, for hiking/climbing/running it is the perfect amount of illumination for the path to see where you are going and not white-out your night vision.

In action, tested between 30 and 50 feet (click the image for details):

Small and LightNot Too BrightAlmost HomePetzl TactikkaCold Tarantula

Fenix T1 Tactical

Rating: 4 / 5

Pros:
Searing 225-lumen output in a small package, good runtime, durable, 2 output levels, spare parts included, price

Cons:
Bulky and a little heavy, twist-select for light output feels “grainy”, orange button, no filters or accessories, odd shape limits mounting options

The Bottom Line:
A great first attempt at a tactical flashlight from Fenix, I look forward to seeing what they come up with next.

Not bad for their first tactical entry. The light is a bit on the heavy side, but really no heavier or larger than a comparable-output Surefire of the same class. Both brand’s entries in this category are too big for pocket carry. The low output setting is pretty bright, but dim enough to be useful in tight quarters. Twisting over to the 225-lumen “turbo” mode is easy, but unfortunately cannot be done one-handed. The built-in clip is sturdy, and as promised the light will stand on end to act as a candle. This works on even a slightly tilted surface despite it’s forward-heavy balance. The “olive” color is definitely a natural olive, not the traditional camo green, and has a significant amount of “gold” in it. Still, it’s a pretty well subdued color and shouldn’t be a problem. Black is also available, on a limited trial-run. The light feels reasonably sturdy, but not nearly as much as a comparable Surefire unit. I’m not sure how much pressure it would take to crush the light, or how big of a fall it could take. The orange tail-cap bothers me a little as well – tactical lights are not to be seen until they are used and orange just doesn’t mesh well with this logic.

I don’t have a 225-lumen capable Surefire at my disposal, so I was unable to compare on even ground. I did run it side-by-side with my 100-lumen Lumamax L4 though, and while certainly brighter I’m not convinced of it’s “more than twice as bright” rating. The other drawback is the lack of available filters and other accessories for the front bezel. Still, when you consider the price is less than a third that of it’s Surefire counterpart, this is a very nice tactical light. Fenix also throws in 3 extra washers, a lanyard, an extra (orange) switch cover and a carry pouch that will work on a belt or clip on to other gear.

All said and done, this is an excellent light with good build quality and a fair price. The number one thing they should work on is getting us a design that supports different color filters. I give it 4.5/5 and recommend it to anyone in need of a good, bright tactical light but unsure of Surefire’s outrageous price tag.

I picked up this unit from Fenix-Store.com with the 4sevens LightBar I ordered, as I said excellent shipping turnaround.

In both output shots below, the Fenix T1 Tactical is on the left at 225 lumens, with a Surefire Lumamax L4 on the right at 100 lumens.

What’s in the box?Size comparison next to a (barely) pocket carry Lumamax L4225-lumen Fenix on left, 100-lumen Surefire on right225-lumen Fenix on left, 100-lumen Surefire on right

Glo-Toob™ Lithium

Rating: 5 / 5

Pros:
Durable, waterproof, crushproof, bright, long battery life

Cons:
A little big for a keychain, price

The backorder on my Glo-Toob™ Lithium finally came in yesterday after a month of waiting. I was initially surprised at just how much bigger the new ‘toob has to be to accommodate the larger 123A battery, this one will no doubt be too big for many people’s keychains. Since I keep little else on my keychain, I find the increased size isn’t a problem.

Glo-Toob Lithium vs. FX on a keychainGlo-Toob Lithium vs. FX on a keychain

In The Box

This lithium version comes with the push-button cap, quick-release neck lanyard and 3500-meter waterproof cap, along with a protective cover for whichever cap is not in use. The waterproof cap is similar in appearance to the standard cap on the FX model, but is designed to prevent the accidental activation the older model often experienced from twisting on it’s attachment point. Instead, the switch is a separate part that spins independently from the base.

Glo-Toob™ LithiumGlo-Toob™ Lithium with waterproof capGlo-Toob™ LithiumGlo-Toob™ Lithium with included accessoriesGlo-Toob™ Lithium push-button cap close-up

Comparison

Well, as I mentioned before it is a little bigger… by about a third. It is also much brighter. In fact, at full power it is so bright that concealed use in some situations might be a problem – though the 25% power-mode is quite reasonable. It also sports 11 different lighting modes, whereas the FX only has 7. The increased lifespan of the 123A battery is a plus, and despite the increased brightness runtime is extended to a total of 30-100 hours. The only real downside on this unit is going to be price. The FX can be picked up for under $20, whereas the Lithium costs upwards of $40.

Glo-Toob™ Lithium vs. Glo-Toob™ FXGlo-Toob™ Lithium vs. Glo-Toob™ FXGlo-Toob™ Lithium vs. Glo-Toob™ FXGlo-Toob™ Lithium vs. Glo-Toob™ FXGlo-Toob™ Lithium vs. Glo-Toob™ FX

Given the increased output and runtime, I’ll probably order one in white to replace the standard Glo-Toob™ I use on my hiking staff.

Surefire L4 LumaMax

Rating: 4.5 / 5

Pros:
Bright, good runtime, useful multi-purpose beam pattern, durable

Cons:
Gets hot during prolonged use, price

My usual impatience waiting on transcontinental warranty service has rewarded me with yet another flashlight. I’ll admit for some time now I’ve wanted to see what all the fuss was about, and if a land-use flashlight with a triple-digit price tag could really be justified. While I’m still not completely convinced on the price, I really like this flashlight – so much in fact, that it’s found its way to daily carry in my pocket instead of the originally intended spot in my bag. It’s small enough to slip quite nicely into a pocket or onto the accessory strap of a certain tactical pant I’m fond of, despite having a better field of vision and brighter output than its Inova counterpart. The optional filters also make a good (and cheap) lens protector while it’s in your pocket, and protect you from the heat after use – and it does get quite hot. Fortunately, it is clearly designed to handle such heat and the unit is just as bright now as it was on day one. The only thing I don’t like about the flashlight is the lack of a rear lanyard attachment point, but as a “pocket” light I haven’t been using a lanyard anyhow.

L4 with filter next to a 3.5" Gerber folder (closed)L4 and red filter next to a 3.5" Gerber folder (open)Testing the L4 on a person at 15 feet, and a vehicle at about 50 feetLighting up the desert - nice peripheral at around 200 feetRunning the red filter, one can still keep the local area well lit, and spot reflectors (or eyes) at around 1000 feetClipped onto the side of a Maxpedition Operator case